Neither side vulnerable. East deals. NORTH S: 5 4 3 H: Q 10 8 6 4 2 D: K J 9 6 C: Void WEST EAST S: A 2 S: J H: A J H: K 7 5 3 D: A Q 10 4 D: 8 7 3 2 C: A 9 8 6 3 C: J 10 5 4 SOUTH S: K Q 10 9 8 7 6 H: 9 D: 5 C: K Q 7 2 The Bidding: EAST SOUTH WEST NORTH Pass 4S Double Pass Pass Pass Opening Lead: AH The player sitting in the West seat has a number of difficult decisions to make during the five or six minutes it takes to bid and play this hand. The first problem is what to bid over South's four spade call. Many partnerships play that a double in this instance is penalty and four no trump is a three suit take out bid. Holding only two hearts is sufficient reason to avoid four no trump. While five clubs is also an alternative, I think it comes down to double or pass. At match point duplicate competition, I would pass. If you defeat four spades you should get a decent score and a double could very easily become a bottom. At team competition it is right to double. The opposition is already in game so it is not going to cost much if the contract is made. From your perspective, that is an unlikely result. The second problem is the opening lead. A good player will not under lead a non-trump ace in this situation, and there is little information available except for the high probability of strange distribution all around. It could be right to start with the ace of spades. For one thing, it won't get trumped. On the other hand, you don't want to smother the singleton king, if your partner happens to have that holding. Of the other three suits, the ace of hearts seems the least likely to be trumped by declarer, and if partner can encourage you might score a quick ruff. Nothing else looks attractive so West leads the ace of hearts and gets a chance to see the dummy. Partner does play an encouraging seven and declarer plays the nine. A second heart lead will probably establish the heart suit in dummy and it is not likely that declarer can do that by himself, which brings us to the third problem, what card does West play to trick two? When this hand was actually played, West, fearing club ruffs in the dummy, played the ace of spades at trick two and the deuce of spades at trick three. Declarer won the third trick in hand and led the five of diamonds. West won the ace and found himself with yet another problem. A heart lead would establish the suit for declarer. A diamond lead would allow for two club discards from the South hand. If the ace of clubs was led, declarer would trump in dummy and discard the last losing club on the king of diamonds. It turns out that the lead of a low club will set the contract, but that is not easy to see. West led a low diamond and declarer played the jack from dummy discarding a club from hand. Another club went away on the king of diamonds. A heart was trumped and the king of clubs led and covered by the ace, ruffed in dummy, at which point declarer claimed his doubled contract. As in most difficult hands, the mistake was really made at trick two. If declarer cashes the ace of diamonds prior to playing the ace of spades and another spade, there will be no problem later in the hand. With three tricks home, if West finds himself on lead he will have already defeated the hand one trick. As it turns out, declarer is unable to set up and enjoy the hearts in dummy, and there are not enough resting places to cover all of the losing clubs. ___________________________________________________________________