Neither side vulnerable. East deals. NORTH S: 9 8 7 5 4 H: J D: Q 7 5 3 C: K 7 2 SOUTH S: K Q J 6 2 H: A 4 3 2 D: A 4 C: J 9 The Bidding: EAST SOUTH WEST NORTH Pass 1S Double 3S Pass 4S Pass Pass Pass Opening Lead: 8D North's three spade bid after the takeout double by West shows a good spade raise with less than ten points. It is meant to be more of a disruptive bid than a constructive one. South felt that his hand was very good and continued on to game. The competition was "rubber bridge" and the game bonus is sufficient justification for South's aggressive bidding. West led the eight of diamonds. The three was played from dummy, East inserted the jack, and South won the ace. Declarer led the king of spades to the second trick. West won the ace while East played the three. Without any apparent hesitation or pause for thought, West placed the three of clubs on the table. Put yourself in declarer's position and determine what card you would play from dummy. You have already lost a spade and you will probably lose a diamond. You must restrict your club losses to only one trick. If you had to play the suit yourself it is likely that you would simply lead toward the king and play West for the ace. This is a 50-50 play. You now have others options, or so it would seem. If West has under led the queen, it is correct to duck. If East has both the ace and the queen, it does not matter what you do, you will be defeated. If West has under led the ace, then you must play the king. Here is the whole hand: NORTH S: 9 8 7 5 4 H: J D: Q 7 5 3 C: K 7 2 WEST EAST S: A 10 S: 3 H: K 9 8 6 H: Q 10 7 5 D: 10 8 2 D: K J 9 6 C: A 10 4 3 C: Q 8 6 5 SOUTH S: K Q J 6 2 H: A 4 3 2 D: A 4 C: J 9 I would guess that most players would call for a low club from dummy at this point, based on the assumtion that West has under led the queen of clubs. In fact, we are taught that it is wrong to under lead an ace against a suit contract. Keep in mind, however, that rules are meant to be broken. Determining the right time to break the rule is the big question. Here, if the defense is entitled to a diamond trick it will not go away, and if declarer has the queen of clubs he will lose only one club trick anyway. But if partner has the queen, there is a chance to beat the contract. Putting declarer to the test early is the right play for this hand. ____________________________________________________________________