North-South vulnerable. West deals. NORTH S: K Q 9 5 3 H: A J 8 D: K 7 C: 10 5 4 WEST EAST S: J 7 2 S: A 10 H: 5 4 3 H: 10 6 D: A Q 10 9 8 6 D: 5 4 3 C: K C: J 9 8 7 6 2 SOUTH S: 8 6 4 H: K Q 9 7 2 D: J 2 C: A Q 3 The Bidding: WEST NORTH EAST SOUTH 2D Double Pass 4H Pass Pass Pass Opening Lead: CK It was late at night when this hand came up at the weekly rubber bridge game. Everyone was tired and the North-South pair were way behind in the rubber. Had West made the pedestrian lead of the three of hearts there would be no story to tell. While declarer can set up the spade suit and come to ten tricks, he can't do this unless he can see all of the cards. The defense should always score four tricks before declarer makes his game. West, however, led the king of clubs! South won the ace and played two rounds of hearts, ending in hand. A small spade was led to the king and ace. East returned a club, ducked by declarer and ruffed by West. West continued with the ace of diamonds and a diamond to the king in dummy. Declarer still had a spade to lose for down one. The winning line of play is to draw three rounds of trump ending in the South hand and then play a spade to the king. East can do no better that to win the ace and return a diamond. West wins the eight plays a diamond to the king. At this point declarer's problem is a lack of entries to the board. He still needs to establish a long spade trick to allow him to discard a club loser. The correct play is a low spade to the eight. It wins in every situation except when East started with four spades to the A-J-10. Unfortunately, declarer did not find the winning play until the ride home. ------------------------------------------------------------------