North-South vulnerable. North deals. NORTH S: 3 H: J 10 6 4 D: A K Q J C: A 9 7 2 WEST EAST S: A J 9 8 4 2 S: K 7 5 H: 7 H: A Q 8 5 3 D: 9 6 3 D: 10 8 7 4 2 C: 10 5 4 C: V o i d SOUTH S: Q 10 6 H: K 9 2 D: 5 C: K Q J 8 6 3 NORTH EAST SOUTH WEST 1D 1H 2C Pass 3C Pass Pass 3S 4C 4S 5C Double Pass Pass Pass Eleven tricks in clubs are there for the taking except for one small thing - the defense gets to start the play of the hand. West has an easy decision, if he doesn't lead a heart (based on his partner's bid), then he doesn't have one. Accordingly, West tables the seven of hearts. East wins the ace and returns the eight to signify that he has an entry in the higher ranking of the other non-trump suits, or in this case, spades. West ruffs the heart return and underleads his ace of spades. East wins the king and leads another small heart for West to ruff. This results in a two trick set worth 500 points for the East-West pair. This is an excellent result no matter what form of competition you are involved in. In the actual situation, the game was team of four and the contract at the other table was three no trump in the South, down three after West led his fourth best spade and the defense ran off six spade tricks and the ace of hearts. The contract was not doubled and East-West only gained 300 points. What went wrong with the auction? All went well until North decided to take action over three spades. He has no reason to bid. After a reasonable pass by North and East, South will no doubt compete with four clubs. If East decides to raise spades the North-South partnership will be in better position to evaluate their defensive prospects and will more than likely double. In any event, they are headed for a better score. There are two important points to be learned from this hand. Don't bid the same values twice. North has already shown his complete hand when he supports clubs at the three level. Bidding four clubs freely (that is when partner is guaranteed to have another chance to bid) is truly an invitational bid as opposed to being competitive. Also, when defending against a suit contract, don't underlead a side suit ace unless you have a specific reason. In this case, partner had raised spades and returned a high heart for West to ruff. This was a strong indication that he had a high spade honor (the ace or the king). Since the defense would only score one spade trick because of the singleton in dummy, it was reasonable to underlead the ace to reach partner's hand for another heart ruff. --------------------------------------------------------------------