Both sides vulnerable. East deals. North S: 7 6 2 H: 4 2 D: 10 8 3 C: A J 9 4 2 West East S: 10 9 5 4 3 S: J 8 H: 8 H: 10 7 D: K 9 4 D: A Q J 6 5 2 C: K Q 8 7 C: 10 6 5 South S: A K Q H: A K Q J 9 6 5 3 D: 7 C: 3 The Bidding: East South West North 2D 4NT Pass 5D Pass 6H (All Pass) Opening lead: KD At a duplicate game in Hilton Head, East opened two diamonds and South had a problem. He decided that all he really wanted to know about was whether or not North held an ace or two. 4NT seemed to be the way to get that information. West asked North what 4NT meant. This gave North the chance to say "Blackwood" and confirm that he was showing aces. It is best, as the player holding the West cards, to not ask this question. North may not pick up on the fact that South is bidding Blackwood and who knows what could happen. The point is, when 4NT comes out of nowhere, it is Blackwood and you should answer appropriately. Think of "Occam's Razor". When faced with any problem, the simplest solution is usually the correct solution. When the results where in, two pairs stopped in game and one pair stopped in a partial. I think that if East had passed, South should open 4NT. Any other bid could lead to many problems.