East-West vulnerable. East deals. North S: K J 10 7 6 2 H: A D: K Q 6 3 C: 10 8 West East S: Void S: 8 H: K J 10 7 3 H: Q 8 4 2 D: 10 8 7 4 D: A 9 C: A Q J 6 C: K 9 7 5 3 2 South S: A Q 9 5 4 3 H: 9 6 5 D: J 5 2 C: 4 The Bidding: East South West North Pass 2S 3H 4S 5H Pass Pass 5S Pass Pass Pass Opening lead: 7H Here is an intersting hand from a Swiss Team event. Each partnership has 20 high card points and yet, they can each make eleven tricks. I held the North hand. My Partner was Bill Cornwell of Hubbard. After East bid five hearts, the auction came back to me and I had to decide how to continue. A pre-emptive bid should indicate minimum defensive values. I thought that I could score two tricks against the five heart contract. I was not sure that my side could take eleven tricks, but it did appear to be a very reasonable bid. If we went down one, it was very likely that they could make. As it turned out, Cornwell was able to claim quickly and we scored up +450. When we compared scores with our team-mates, we found that they had also bid to the five level and when the opponents made the same five spade bid, they had doubled, so their score was -650. The difference was worth five IMPs (International Match Points) for the opponents. There is a school of thought that says you should always double the opponents when they outbid you at the five level in a competitive auction. If they make it, it is going to be a bad board whether it is at matchpoints or at teams. If they go down, you should maximize your results. Even though it did not work out this time, I think my team-mates were correct in making this double. _______________________________________________________